Quick Search

626 Partial failure of PC tank unit on installation

Report ID: 626

Published: Newsletter No 46 - April 2017

Report Overview

The use of precast concrete units to construct water retaining structures is becoming more common but their safe installation is not as straightforward as may be suggested.

Report Content

The use of precast concrete units to construct water retaining structures is becoming more common. Their safe installation however, says a reporter, is not as straightforward as may be suggested.

During construction of such a tank, one of the precast units’ integral stabilising feet failed as the unit was being installed. The tank comprised units up to 8m high which were placed on an insitu base slab. The foot failure was attributed to the use of shims and a steel wrecking bar used when attempting to plumb the unit. Prior to the incident, 8 units had been placed without damage. A unit was then lifted into place and with the load still on the crane, it was plumbed by placing shims under RC stabilising feet. A steel bar was used as a pry to help placing the shims. As the load from the crane was released, one of the feet failed, making the unit unstable.

The use of shims, particularly under the body of the unit (as well as the feet) raised concerns regarding the temporary stability of the units prior to their incorporation into the parent structure. After an investigation, the following measures were taken:

  1. Where shims were required under the main body of the unit, temporary props were provided to stabilise units.
  2. Construction supervision was increased to ensure even distribution of shims under the units and the addition of grout where necessary.

Many of the issues might have been negated by the provision of a flatter base slab making excessive shimming unnecessary. That said, the provision of a suitably ‘super flat’ slab and the residual requirement to place shims under the unit’s feet would negate many of the advantages otherwise attributable to precast concrete construction of tanks.

Comments

This shows the need to consider the practicalities of installation when developing an overall design. All construction has tolerances and all items (whether in precast concrete or other material) will require adjustment to achieve alignment so the fittings need to be ‘robust’. A robust design ought also to ensure there is no gross change in state consequent on minor damage. In this case, there should have been no overturning risk if any of the items attached to aid stability had been damaged. Combinations of adverse tolerances need to be considered as part of component design.

Images

Damaged panel foot


Underside



Email Updates

How to Report

Online submission:
Submit by post: